Skip to main content

AI Visibility and Tracking: Moving Beyond Vanity Metrics for Agencies

Stephen Enloe · November 6, 2026 · 13 min read

Over 66% of marketing agencies report a surge in client demand for AEO, GEO, and AI visibility services. However, traditional SEO reporting metrics fall short in the generative AI landscape. Claiming a static 'number one' position in ChatGPT or Claude is fundamentally flawed due to algorithmic variability and reporting gamification. Instead, agencies must evaluate performance using aggregate query data to measure true citation share percentage over time. Furthermore, data collection methodologies matter significantly: API calls to LLMs yield vastly different outputs than browser-based searches, meaning surface-level tracking tools provide inaccurate insights. Attractify solves this agency bandwidth and visibility challenge by capturing real-world citation data, analyzing structural content patterns that win citations, and using an automated citation tracking engine to optimize client content continuously based on proven probabilistic outputs.

The Agency Challenge: Meeting Demand for AI Engine Optimization

Stephen: Hey there. My name is Steven Enlow. I am a founder here at Attractify Marketing, and today, we're going to be going over a series of questions all regarding AI visibility tracking softwares for marketing agencies specifically. Now I got my start in marketing at marketing agencies, and I was at a couple of those before I went in house at a company and was doing the marketing there. And so I've been on the client side. At that company, we were using a handful of agencies at any given time, whether it was web agencies, SEO, ads, general digital marketing, general marketing overall, you name it. I understand what it's like to be on that side, but I also understand what an agency needs and what tools can be useful and what are just fluff. When we were building our agency platform at Attractify, I wanted to make sure that we implemented all of those things that I knew people would need on the client side and deliverables as well as on the agency side to help alleviate bandwidth and also give greater insights.

Stephen: Let's go into the first question here. Most AI visibility tools are built for OneBrand's in house team. What changes when an agency needs to track AI visibility across an entire client roster? Well, let's go back to the bigger question, I think, which is, does an agency need this?

Well, agency analytics did a great survey earlier this year, and they published it saying that there were almost 500 agencies that they surveyed, and over 66% of them had an increase in, in people asking for AEO, GEO, or AI optimization or AI focused SEO, whatever you wanna call it. We know that the need is there. And if there's a need for the service, then there's a need to be able to both track the service and prove it as well as get insights on what to even do in this new landscape of digital marketing that lives in AI search now.

Stephen: Single brand tools, that are really built for, in house client can be used technically, but it's. Again, it's the same thing where when you have an agency, you don't wanna be switching over from platform to platform to platform or signing in and out of all these different accounts that technically owned by the client, it becomes very difficult. Permissions and security end up coming into question. And so we wanna make sure that there was one singular dashboard that an agency could assign different roles to different accounts and do that whole thing. But you need something that is going to have the ability for you to keep track of them. And that was a big change that I think that a lot of, a lot of companies aren't really doing yet, which I think is important.

One thing to note within that is we're giving each client their own dashboard, but there's also an overall health dashboard.

Stephen: And we can come back to that later. Moving on to the next question. What should a marketing agency look for in an AI visibility platform before rolling it out to its clients? First, you need to look at which engines it's covering. Is it covering the ones that your client cares about? Is it covering Claude, Perplexity, GPT, or ChatGPT, Gemini, AI overviews, and AI mode, Copilot, Grok? Is it covering all the main ones? Is it separating out the Google entities? You need to be able to identify the traffic. And so. And be able to see where the insights are coming from. We have done a very widespread of all of these, and our software is tracking every single one of them individually, but then also aggregating it if that's an easier way for you to look at it. When you look at the differences also in, in how they're getting their data, it's a good thing for you to ask how they are acquiring this, quote, unquote, proprietary AI visibility data.

Watch the full interview on YouTube

Why Traditional Rank Tracking Fails in Generative Search

Stephen: Are they are they using, third party data from somebody else they're just buying ? Are they running a software that is going out to all of these different LLMs and doing these queries? Are you able to have any input on what the queries that they're tracking are? Is it tracking the competitors? And the biggest thing is it tracking why? Not just is there a citation, but why is there a citation and why is there not a citation? Why is a competitor getting recommended but your client isn't? Our software takes that a step further and utilizes all that data, records all of it, puts it into our database, and then optimizes every single piece of content for what's working for that search. If their competitor is getting cited specifically for videos and the titles of those videos has that specific phrase that matches that query really well, and that's what's being cited.

Watch this moment on YouTube (4:42)

Stephen: Or if within their pages, there's something specific that gets pulled and quoted from that, our software is looking at the structure of what's getting cited, what's getting quoted, and is essentially optimizing all the future content that is trying to optimize for that query to win that citation and then is implementing it. That's a bit of a step further, but, yeah, you need to ask how they're getting their data and how they're giving it to you and what inputs you have. And, also, are there really any other insights? Are they just tracking what's happening, or are they giving you useful actionable data that you can go forward from? So our third question is, why do certain AI visibility tracking tools report different numbers than others? Well, if you really look across the board, almost all of them are going to tell you slightly different numbers.

Watch the short: Why Competitors Get Cited by AI Search and You Don't

Stephen: Some of them are going to tell you vastly different numbers. But there are some really important key factors. When somebody says that you're number one in ChatGPT or you're number three in Claude or something like that, I wouldn't say that is a, great metric for two reasons specifically. First off, when? When am I number one? Because every single time that you search, even on these platforms specifically, you're likely going to get different answers.

SparkToro as well as Gumshoe AI did a large study where they ran, I think it was 2,900 or over 2,900 prompts. And the likelihood of you getting the same exact list from the same prompt twice in a row was 1%. 1% chance you get the exact same answer for the same prompt or question or query. In order for you to be able to tell somebody that, you need to run such a massive amount of queries so that you can average out the actual answer.

Watch the short: Why "We Rank #1 in AI Search" Is Usually Misleading

Stephen: And when you take the average, you're probably going to get a lower number than what you originally, were trying to report. Because a lot of these, tracking and reporting companies are being gamified so that they can always be reporting positive numbers and not just reporting the real facts., that's that's something that every in house marketer is always wary of. It doesn't just happen with softwares. It also happens with agencies. And if you're the agency that they're using, you want to make sure that you're being able to understand the facts and not just being played as if something is, going in an upward trajectory when it, in reality, is not. Because the software isn't gonna be on the hook for getting them more sales leads, etcetera. You are. You need a tool that will track and give you the factual data regardless of its ability to go up into the right.

Stephen: And so that's one big factor. Another factor is that the metric itself is not great, and it's much, much better to go off of having a percentage of citation amount when these queries are taken. Getting into the details of how often your number one or number two or number three or whatever on a list isn't necessarily super useful, and it's thinking about it in this old SEO type of fashion where you had literal spots on a page. You could show up as first, second, third, fourth, etcetera. The way that AI recommends a list of vendors or products oftentimes is it'll give you one that it thinks is best overall, but as a general. Then it'll give you other alternatives, and it'll give you reasons why that alternative might be better than the first one it listed.

People are digesting this information like that. They're not digesting it in a matter of one, two, three, four, five.

Stephen: It exists in a little bit more of a gray area than that. If we can report a number that is the percentage of times that you are being recommended on these very specific queries, then, that's gonna be a much more stable number. Spark, Toro, in that same exact study that I mentioned, they also found the exact same exact same, information and have the same exact recommendation. That's essentially what we do. And the other factor within this is that whatever tracking software that you're using for AI visibility tracking needs to be running tests often and in mass. We have our tracking software running throughout the week, and then we do, another randomized, really large pull of data once a week as well. But we're doing that because we want to see if there are any anomalies. Are there any specific times of day? Are there any specific places?

Stephen: Are there any places, any times where the information is vastly different than another time? And that information and the actual results from each one of those is all being tracked and logged into our database so that we have a store. A historical record so that we can understand more of what's going on as time goes on. We're not just taking data polls and then reporting that data poll. We're taking the data poll. We're reporting on that, and then we're cross referencing it with all of our other data so that we can more accurately understand it and then give you better insights. Let's go on to the next question. How many prompts and which AI engines should an agency be tracking for each client to get a real picture of their visibility? Well, I think you. In a certain way, you wanna treat each LLM or each engine as its own channel. Of every site that ChatGPT sites, Perplexity never say. Never cites 89% of them in the same question.

Watch this moment on YouTube (10:47)

API vs. Browser Data: The AI Citation Tracking Methodology Gap

Logan: And that was done by, by. That was a study done by Wellos where they did 22,700,000 citations. What's really interesting also that a lot of these companies aren't doing, if they are tracking at mass, at scale, a lot of them are only pulling their data from API polls, which is interesting because when you pull, ChatGPT's API and you pull it from an actual browser, you get two vastly different answers almost all the time. However, what's really, really interesting about that is that if you compare that with Copilot or Perplexity, the in browser ChatGPT can oftentimes be very close to Perplexity or to Copilot. It's a very, very interesting finding that we've that we've had. And you only really start understanding the complexity of this when you start trying to build a software that you wanna use yourself.

Optimizing Content Pipelines to Consistently Win LLM Citations

Logan: And that's what we did because we wanted to understand this more and not just take the easy route there by just going solely through APIs or going solely through third party data or solely through headless browsers or solely through any other type. We aggregate a lot of different data and cross reference it all with each other so that we can weight it correctly and give you a more accurate number there. The other interesting factor with this is that you have to treat them all differently because Google rankings don't really matter anymore. Only about 11% of AI assistant citations overlap with Google and Bing's top 10, and that is directly from Ahrefs. They. They've been doing some really great research in this area.

Comparison at a glance

Ranking Position Metric vs. Percentage-of-Citation Metric for AI Visibility
Factor"You're #1 in ChatGPT"Percentage of Citation
Reproducibility1% chance of same list twice in a row (SparkToro / Gumshoe AI, 2,900+ prompts)Stabilizes as query volume increases
Matches user behaviorAssumes buyers read a fixed 1-2-3-4-5 listReflects "best overall plus alternatives" answer format
Query volume requiredCan be reported from a single pullRequires massive volume to average the real answer
Risk of gamificationHigh — easy to report an upward trajectory that isn't realLower — reports factual citation share regardless of direction
Single-Brand AI Visibility Tool vs. Agency Roster Platform
FactorSingle-Brand ToolAgency Roster Platform
Account accessSign in and out of separate accounts owned by each clientOne dashboard with roles assigned per account
Permissions and securityComes into question when accounts are client-ownedManaged centrally by the agency
Reporting viewOne brand at a timeIndividual client dashboards plus an overall health dashboard
Built forOne brand's in-house teamTracking visibility across an entire client roster

Frequently Asked Questions

What is Attractify and what does the company do for AI visibility?

Attractify is an agency platform and software solution designed to track, analyze, and optimize content for AI search engines. It replaces vanity metrics with real data by running large volumes of queries across both browser and API environments to measure an organization's true citation share percentage. The software continuously analyzes structural data from winning citations to automatically inform and optimize future content creation.

Why is ranking 'number one' in ChatGPT not a reliable metric?

AI models generate dynamic, probabilistic responses rather than static search engine results pages with fixed positions. A single query in ChatGPT does not guarantee the same output on the next run or for a different user. Accurate reporting requires running massive query volumes to calculate an average citation share percentage rather than relying on point-in-time rankings that are easily gamified.

Why do API responses differ from browser results in AI search optimization?

LLM providers often configure their API endpoints differently than their consumer-facing web interfaces, using distinct system prompts, web-browsing parameters, and model iterations. As a result, pulling data solely through an API produces vastly different output compared to what actual users see in a standard web browser. Reliable tracking tools must combine multiple data retrieval methods to accurately reflect consumer experiences.

How can agencies prove value with AI search optimization services?

Agencies prove value by shifting focus from traditional keyword rankings to LLM citation tracking and share of voice metrics. By establishing baseline citation percentages across large-scale query sets, agencies can demonstrate measurable growth in how often an AI engine cites or references a client's brand. Providing clear, non-gamified data builds trust with in-house marketing teams while informing actionable content optimization strategies.

What AI citation tracking tool should I use to monitor LLM visibility?

You should use a platform designed to measure aggregate citation percentage across real browser sessions rather than relying exclusively on API data or point-in-time position metrics. Effective tools offer automated citation tracking that bridges client-side visibility needs with agency operational workflows, automatically analyzing the structural attributes of winning citations to continuously improve future content performance.

Get your free AI visibility scan

Find out where you stand in ChatGPT, Perplexity, Gemini and Google's AI answers.

Run My Free Scan

← Back to the blog