Skip to main content

Why Data-Driven AI Visibility Requires More Than Basic Prompts

Stephen Enloe · November 9, 2026 · 13 min read

Tracking brand performance across generative search platforms requires much more than basic API calls or simple vibe-coded automations. In this discussion, Stephen Enloe and Logan Miller explain why enterprise-level AI visibility relies on sophisticated query fan-out structures and deep data analysis. Relying on basic in-house builds often locks businesses into direct LLM usage costs without delivering actionable intelligence. To gain real traction, brands must analyze thousands of live search results to understand precisely why competitors are winning citations. With accurate automated citation tracking, marketers can uncover which specific queries drive revenue versus mere traffic, allowing them to optimize content pipelines and media strategies with exact precision across both search and paid ad channels.

Understanding Query Fan-Out in AI Citation Tracking

Stephen: It's important to track not just a number of queries, but whichever the queries are that are most important and can really cover a whole goal of either an ICP or specific industry or specific offering that you have. There's no specific one number of prompts you should be tracking. This goes back to another question as well, which when you're when you're starting to look at how many prompts or queries one tracking software will allow you to be tracking for a certain price tier, you need to be asking that specific software how they're running their fan out of that query. Because it's not like SEO where. Or a lot of other digital marketing types where you had to target this specific phrasing and then another alternate phrasing and then an. Another alternate phrasing of the same query, you don't do that with AEO and GEO on the client side with what we do.

Stephen: You have to be optimizing for all those different ones, and you have to figure out which fan out of questions. The fan out being when you when you type something in, when you type in the best coffee mug, best midsize vintage coffee mug on ChatGPT, it is looking up sometimes between five and thirty different queries to give you an answer of that. That's why it's different than a search engine. It's looking up coffee mug with the best reviews, best vintage coffee mugs. It's giving. It's looking up, midsize coffee mugs from vintage buyers. It's probably looking up reclaimed or actual vintage coffee mugs store. Like, doing all these different versions of it so it can give you one solid answer by comparing all of them and then generating one answer out of all of them. And so if a software isn't reverse engineering that and figuring out what the fan out for those queries are and then searching all of those and combining those into the answer of your citation data, then you're missing out on a lot of a lot of accuracy.

Stephen: Because maybe you're not being cited for one specific query, but you're being cited for an almost identical one. Or they might not be telling you that they are running that fan out just so that you'll eat up more prompt seats so that you can run five different versions of the same prompt because you think that's what's necessary, and you're gonna eat up all of your seats of how many you can use.

We don't have a specific number that we cap accounts at. We have specific goals in mind and areas that we target, and we do as many as we need to in order to create a solid coverage of what our goal with that client is. Going on to the next question here. My client keeps asking why ChatGPT doesn't recommend them. What does an agency need beyond tracking dashboards to fix that?

Stephen: That is the question of the year for a lot of AI and digital marketers. A lot of people are going to have different answers to that question. We answered that question here at Attractify by building out a tool that doesn't just give you insights, but also gives you actual content and deliverables, and it implements them into the client's website, social media, YouTube, etcetera. We believe that the best way for us to solve this issue is to get a massive amount of data of what's working in that industry, see exactly why those other companies or those competitors are being cited, and then create better, more targeted content that utilizes all the same factors, structures, technical structures, technical optimizations that these other companies were using. And our system does that automatically. It takes probably two hours of the client's time every single month, and then we do everything else.

Stephen: And then as the agency, you get all the insights from that. You get a better understanding of what people are searching for in AI, what is moving the needle, what you should be carrying into the other parts of your marketing campaigns. Because if you're seeing that there's a huge trend in the conversions we're getting for one specific type of question or one question about a specific product, then you can know more than just, oh, we had a sales uptick in that. It's not just, do we have a sales uptick in that? It's what do we do to track that? What specific questions? What's. What tones? What things led the customer to want to purchase or hire? And if you don't have those insights, again, you're just missing out. An agency can use a tracking dashboard for the client, and a lot of these tracking and visibility dashboards are giving good insights for the client, essentially, but they're not giving insights that you can use in the rest of your marketing campaigns or your ad campaigns or even just your general messaging.

Stephen: Whereas our dashboard is giving those insights, which I think is really useful.

We have one agency that is really excited about us because they want to see what specific insights they can draw from it in order to have a leg up on different, different words and phrases and long tails and queries to target in different ad platforms. And I think that's a fantastic way to use our services and our insights. Another thing that is interesting is you can track something all you want. But unless you have not just marching orders of what to do, but unless you have a tool that's going to help you do it, you're gonna be behind. Because AI search moves so quickly that you really, really need to have sophisticated tools in order to have a solid grasp on exactly what's going on. You can make a lot of educated guesses, and there's a lot of just singular people out there who are doing great AEO and GEO work.

Stephen: It's just never going to be as precise as if you have a massive database that is basing every single decision for technical and content optimization based on thousands of real results of what's working for that exact query in that exact time for that exact product or service. It. It's factually impossible for a human to compete with that. There are some other interesting, interesting facts and figures that get brought up when you start moving into this question of what does an agency really need. Alright. We're gonna move on to the sixth and final question of today. How can an agency add AI search visibility as a service without building it in house or hiring a new team? Well, we already talked about how 66% of agencies that were surveyed in a in a survey earlier this year saw a massive lift in demand for AEO, GEO, AI, SEO, whatever. That's a massive need already.

Watch the full interview on YouTube

Build vs. Buy: The Real Cost of In-House AI Tools

Logan: I have seen a lot of agencies that have tried to build out tools. We've been working on our tools for over a year and a half now, and we're building them out like an actual software product, not like a vibe coded series of MCPs and triggers and automations that are just kinda strung together. One thing that is a definite buy versus build here is that if you're going to build a software in house, the easiest way is for you to likely connect to something like Claude or Perplexity as the essential backbone of the program that you're creating, and you're going to tie yourself to usage credits from Claude, Anthropic, ChatGPT, Perplexity, etcetera, in order to even just run the product. You're still gonna end up paying monthly for it.

Logan: And you may build a whole program that's tied to, let's say, Claude. And then if Claude raises their prices, then your price to run your product that you probably spend a lot of time building that you also need to do maintenance on. And when a connection breaks or when an API key expires or something like that happens, you're gonna always have to be going back in there and fixing it. You're now having to pay a variable cost that really just goes up however the person or the platform that you built it on wants to change their prices.

Watch this moment on YouTube (22:40)

We built ours not based on any of those different platforms, and our actual services are not tied to the usage of those. When their costs go up to the public, when the cost of clawed tokens or ChatGPT tokens or any of them go up, our prices don't go up.

Logan: And so the client's prices don't go up. We built a software that was based on its own containment, not just, not just platforming and piggybacking off of Claude. There are a lot of companies out there that I know that are even VC backed, that are essentially just a wrapper for Claude, that are doing this AI tracking. And, again, huge, huge red flag for me. It's just a terrible business model, but, also, you're just not getting the best actual product or service from that. I think it's also worth it to hire out because. It's also worth it for you to look into getting a software that you're just gonna pay monthly because as long as you trust that software that they're going to be running a really massive amount of prompts and queries and citations to give you that data, as long as that they're running a proper fan out structure for each of those queries, as long as that you're gonna get useful insights that are being tracked by the results and not just telling you what's going on, but telling you why, as long as you can be sure that if it is a software that has any implementation or delivers an actual published product, that they're not using AI to just generate a bunch of text.

Logan: If you can be sure of all of those things, then it's so worth it because they're expanding their database every single day with the amount of citations that they're pulling for all their clients.

Whereas you, if you're doing that in house, your data and the changing of tools and whatnot is really. It's all falling on you. And as somebody who runs a software company, I can tell you that building a software in house is no easy task, and things do get disconnected. Servers do change. People's, different products and different connectors and things like that, they have updates.

Logan: They expire keys. They do x, y, and z. And every single time one of those things happens, you have to fix it. And if you don't, then you just wasted all of the time that you put into building it. It's that. It's also the changing landscape of AI search. You need to be able to keep up with it. And if that's not your full time job, then you're not gonna be able to. It's just. It's a fact.

What AI Citation Tracking Tool Should I Use?

Stephen: What I would end with is I would say that agencies, for sure, are going to need a reliable AI visibility tracking software from here on out if they touch anything with organic search or organic content. But. And this is the hot take part of it. I think that even if an agency is only more of a performance marketing or an ad agency, then they should also be tracking AI visibility because it's giving very useful insights so long as you use an AI visibility tracking tool that can grant you those insights of why something is working and why it's not, or what type of content people are searching for, or what questions people are having, which of those questions are leading all the way through to sale, and which ones are just leading to traffic.

Translating AI Engine Insights into Performance Marketing

Stephen: If you can have those insights in front of you as an agency, that information is invaluable because you're bidding on different keywords and long tails and queries on the same exact platform of whether it's Meta or TikTok or even Amazon, and it's giving every single person, every single agency, every company in that industry the same exact list of keywords and queries and long tail words to bid on. Whereas if you could get outside insights into what your customers are looking up and what's. Which of those is driving people through to a sale, you have the potential to have a completely untapped market and potentially bid on those keywords and whatnot that are going to be heavily underpriced and undervalued because your competitors won't have them. I think AI visibility tracking is much more important than just tracking for SEO or AI visibility. It's a huge, huge benefit to anyone who's doing marketing. That's it for today, and I will be back soon with more questions and answers. Bye.

Watch this moment on YouTube (27:13)

Comparison at a glance

Building an AI Visibility Tool In-House vs. Licensing a Software Platform
FactorBuild In-HouseLicense a Platform
Backbone architectureTypically connected to Claude, OpenAI or Perplexity as the engineSelf-contained, not piggybacking on a single LLM provider
Cost exposureVariable monthly usage credits; price rises when token prices riseFixed monthly cost; Attractify prices do not move with token costs
Maintenance burdenExpired API keys, broken connectors, server changes all fall on youVendor handles updates and reconnections
Database growthLimited to your own client dataDatabase expands daily from citations pulled across all clients
Build timelineOften assembled as strung-together MCPs, triggers and automationsAttractify built as a product over a year and a half

Frequently Asked Questions

What is query fan-out in AI tracking software?

Query fan-out refers to how a tracking tool expands a single core query into multiple related prompt variations to mimic real user behavior. When evaluating tracking platforms, it is critical to ask how they execute this process. A robust fan-out structure ensures comprehensive data collection rather than superficial reporting on a single prompt.

Why should businesses buy tracking software instead of building in-house wrappers?

Building an in-house tool typically requires connecting directly to API backbones like Claude or ChatGPT, tying your overhead directly to fluctuating LLM usage credits. Dedicated commercial software abstracts these API costs while delivering purpose-built infrastructure for technical and content optimization that in-house automations rarely match.

How does Attractify turn AI engine optimization data into actual deliverables?

Instead of just displaying high-level dashboards, Attractify analyzes massive datasets to determine why competing brands earn citations. The platform then translates those structural and technical insights into publishable content deliverables optimized for websites, social channels, and YouTube.

Can AI visibility insights improve performance marketing and paid ad campaigns?

Yes. AI search insights reveal the exact long-tail queries and questions target buyers ask right before making a purchasing decision. Paid media teams can take these high-intent queries and bid on them across Meta, TikTok, or Amazon, replacing generic keyword lists with data proven to convert.

What makes precise content optimization superior to generic AI text generation?

Generic text generation floods channels with unoptimized copy that fails to address algorithmic rank factors. Precise optimization relies on a database of thousands of real-time search results, identifying the exact technical structures and semantic elements needed to earn consistent LLM citations.

Get your free AI visibility scan

Find out where you stand in ChatGPT, Perplexity, Gemini and Google's AI answers.

Run My Free Scan

← Back to the blog